To Wear or Not to Wear: The Jilbab

By Bianca Rajan

Here in West Kalimantan I am living and working in my first Muslim community. My time here has been shaped through my constant interpretation of cultural and religious differences. The jilbab, or head-scarf that covers a Muslim woman’s head is one of the most dynamic sources of conversation for my friends here and family back home. I have chosen to write on this topic, over other equally or more important aspects of Islam, for three reasons. The first is that the jilbab is the most immediate and noticeable physical difference between a Muslim Indonesian woman and myself. For the first two months of my grant I felt that difference every day in class at SMA Muhammadiyah (a private Islamic high school). The second is that there was a previous article written by ETAs that talked about their choice to wear the jilbab as a part of their assimilation and this is listed as one of Indonesiaful’s most popular articles, so it must be an area of interest for our two societies. The third is because I have really struggled with understanding the jilbab myself, due to having no previous exposure to Islam and the fact that I live in a city on the equator. It is HOT. The first couple months of my grant you may have heard me use the words “jilbab, long sleeves” and “torture” in the same sentence.

10405372_10152849660898330_3557938484510582225_nMost Islamic women in Pontianak choose when and where they wish to wear the jilbab. The aforementioned sentence pertains to me specifically, as I am the only un-jilbabed woman walking around my school. I often do not recognize my female students outside of school because many teen girls choose not to wear it in Pontianak. Female high school students who respond to my probing questions on why they are not wearing a jilbab outside of school never fail to answer with an abashed “I am not ready”.

I thought wearing the jilbab inside the walls of a Muhammadiyah would be a black and white scenario. If my school specifically asked me to wear it as a part of my uniform then I planned to oblige, but they never asked me to. However, on the first day one of my co-teachers mentioned I would look “more beautiful” in a jilbab. I didn’t know how to answer this statement, whether I should interpret it as a subtle suggestion or just overanalyze it in all the ways that I did. I later asked another teacher to clarify and she replied that “no, if you wish to wear it to fit in, or show respect for the culture, then wear it. But if you wear it, we want it to be your choice.”

IMG_3627

Traditional Malay Islamic dress for fancy occasions.

It was my choice. This pushed me to think more critically about the purpose of the jilbab and what it represented to those around me. In Pontianak when a woman wears a jilbab it identifies her as a Muslim women, which often means a Malay women, because the Chinese and Dayak are Christian, and our population (I’ve heard, there are no online statistics) is approximately 60% Chinese and 30% Malay. The Malay are historically Muslim, but have actually only recently begun to wear the jilbab. For example, one of my colleagues told me that her mother’s generation were the first to wear it.

“Until recent decades the wearing of
the headscarf… was not widespread.
In Indonesia, the reformist movement promoted the wearing of the jilbab for women in the 1920s and 1930s. However, while it was a clearly recognised symbol of piety, it is only since the 1980s that it has become more accepted and popular there.”[i]

Popular is an interesting word because in Pontianak and other larger cities in Indonesia, one cannot help but notice the plethora of pinning styles and patterns that go along with the bright jilbabs, in addition to the tight jeans, matching lipstick, and stiletto heels underneath it. A Jakarta Post opinion article talks about the “jilboob”, referring to the covered head and neck accompanied with a tight breast-emphasizing shirt or dress. It discusses how modern day Indonesia may be just developing in it’s own unique evolution in female dress codes. Furthermore, it can also be seen as signifying confidence and assertiveness in a woman’s own culture and religion “some consider the phenomenon of the hijab and the niqab as being related to the rise of the politics of identity within the Muslim community as a way to fight against the influence of Western culture”[ii]. It is not only in Indonesia that Muslim women’s fashion choices are evolving as

“Muslim women in the West are also increasingly wearing the jilbab. A young student in France said, ‘I get strange looks when I wear my headscarf around town. Some have a look
of pity, that says ‘poor girl, she is oppressed’”, and the editor of a leading Muslim magazine said, “Modesty is only one of many reasons why a woman wears a scarf. It can be a very political choice too.” [iii]

10696189_10152886947573330_9077580426453412306_n

Girls dress up in jilbabs occasionally at a young age for cultural, religious, and acclimatization purposes.

The question whether it is religious, cultural or political is interesting because “if you ask 10 different women why they’re wearing jilbab, you’ll get 10 different answers,”[iv] according to Jetti R. Hadi, the editor in chief of Noor, a magazine specializing in Muslim fashion. This has been my experience as well. The debate is lively, but can also stray from my original question about the jilbab at my school, Muhammadiyah, and perhaps making a political statement through dress isn’t in the minds of the young Muslim women in Pontianak.

So what about in high schools? Among scholars of Islam it seems there is much debate and various interpretations pertaining to the exact text from the Qur’an, but it is widely established that the jilbab’s function, in religious educational institutions, is for women to be close to Allah (God), because it is his demand to cover the areas considered “aurat”, which refers to the intimate parts of the human body that should be clothed. The aim is to put boys and girls as equals in the educational realm, so that a girl is seen as modest and not judged for her beauty, but her intelligence. Following this notion, at SMA Muhammadiyah 1 in Pontianak, my female students are required to wear the jilbab on campus. My co-teachers make sure it is tight and minimal hair is showing, often adjusting it for them during class in an affectionate or scolding manner. The white jilbabs, boasting the school’s Muhammadiyah-Logoemblem of Muhammadiyah Islamic organization, are a part of the uniform. Yet, unlike most Muslim schools, our female students wear pants because of motorcycle riding safety concerns. This demonstrates the adaptability and autonomy many Muslim institutions have to fit their community’s needs.

“School uniforms vary in Indonesia, some schoolgirls wearing the jilbab in combination with a long grey skirt, or just the headscarf. Others can be seen wearing jeans and jilbabs, erupting from their educational institutions and slinging a leg over the rear saddle of their boyfriend’s motorbike as they zoom off. Worn this way the jilbab combines modernity with an Indonesian Islamic identity, an Indonesian style informed by familiarity with international fashion.”[v]

The jilbab is indeed a significant part of Islam, and marks a physical difference between our societies. But I must say, that after acclimating for five months here, and beginning to wear sweaters all the time I’m starting to realize it’s not so hot to an Indonesian, and after spending five months not wearing a jilbab in a Muslim high school, it has become just a piece of fabric over my students’ heads that displays their ties to a strong religious faith and identity. Their right to wear it is as much as my right to not, and I thank SMA Muhammadiyah for giving me this opportunity to truly feel that.

IMG_3838

Sources:

[i] Sue Ingham and Wulandani Dirgantoro. “Identity, Religion, Repression, or Fashion? The Indonesian Jilbab.” BroadSheetT 25 (n.d.): n. pag. Web. 2 Feb. 2015.

[ii] Fachrudin, Azis Anwar. “‘Jilbab’ Phenomenon: Religious or Cultural?” The Jakarta Post. The Jakarta Post, 12 Sept. 2014. Web. 3 Feb. 2015.

[iii] Ingham. “Identity, Religion, Repression, or Fashion.

[iv] Norimitsu Onishi. “Head Scarf Emerges as Indonesia Political Symbol.” The New York Times. The New York Times, n.d. Web.

[v] Ingham . “Identity, Religion, Repression, or Fashion.

About the author: Bianca Rajan is a Fulbright English Teaching Assistant in Pontianak, West Kalimantan (commonly known as Borneo). She graduated from Washingtion and Jefferson College in Pennsylvania, with a degree in Art and International Studies. Bianca is originally from Maui, Hawai’i where she would like to note she had previously no exposure to the Muslim culture/religion, which is the motivation behind actively learning more about Islam, and writing these articles.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “To Wear or Not to Wear: The Jilbab

  1. I enjoyed your article Bianca! Although one thing I have struggled with is that when ETAs who are women consider whether or not to wear a headscarf, we rarely talk about the fact that we make that decision as people from the United States, where Muslim women face who cover their hair can face prejudice, microagressions and (as the recent news proves) even death, and whether or not having christian privielege in the U.S. should inform our decision to wear hijab in Indonesia.

  2. I Feel like slapped by this article. Its amazing thought by a foreigner where particularly didn’t living in Muslim environment.
    I’m a girl and Im just wear jilbab in school and some religious thing like qur’an recitation , or muslim events. Well, you ever asked me too about “why I don’t wear hijab” and I said the same answer like this article. Using hijab in equator places didn’t make you feel more hot , because the sun doesn’t directly brighten to your head. I feel more safety and comfortable, but the way that I don’t use hijab for now is because I’m very simple person, im not fashionable person. Usually, im just wearing a tshirt and pants. Thats all I wear everyday outside of school.

    I don’t use hijab for now because I feel a little complicated to use that. Even for simple hijab , sometime I need my mom to help me wear it. Its hard to explain , but I mean i don’t like something which made things even more complicated. Aaahhh.. thats very bad argument , but this is what I felt about hijab.

  3. Hi Bianca. I’m Nurir. It’s always nice to read article from Indonesiaful including yours.
    It’s good that you have wonderful time in Pontianak.

    Talking about hijab or jilbab in our religious community is definitely a huge discussion. Here in Madura, and Island belong to East Java, All Schools (especially in my hometown, Pamekasan), makes hijab or jilbab compulsary. My local gov has program called ‘Gerbang Salam’ which stand for the movement to islamic community. But yes, students are free whether to wear or not to wear it outside schools. Well, we first think that the regulation was wrong force for the students, because we believe that wearing hijab should be a decision comes from our heart and not something coming from false force.

    However, students get accustomed to it and fortunately most of them feels it more comfortable wearing hijab than not. Elder citizens though, wears more simple hijan with monochrome and single color. 🙂

    I am agree that you should not wear hijab. I wish you have good times here in Indonesia.

    Best regards
    Nurir

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s